“How long will you be around?” Turnover, school closings, and community stability

 A sign a student held up in one of the recent school closings meetings read, “My family has lived in this community for over 60 years.  I am the third generation to attend Talcott School.  How long will you be around, Duncan Huberman Mazany Brizard Byrd-Bennett?”  The sign underscores how school closings not only harm specific communities but also disrespect community values.  School closings disregard the continuity, history, and commitment that make communities strong.  The string of Chicago Public Schools CEOs referred to in the student’s sign begs the question: if CPS can’t maintain stability and continuity in its own leadership, how can it presume to impose drastic decisions on communities that have integrity and staying power?

When students, parents, and teachers plead with the CPS Board to keep their neighborhood schools open, they talk about school as a family, as an extension of home.  They emphasize the importance of constancy, stability, trust, and respect – all the qualities that help human beings grow in community.  They talk about the ways their schools fight to remain a healthy community in dangerous times and places, and to connect the community with wider cultural opportunities, thorough creative and dynamic partnerships. 

In a family, each person is valued for who they are, and encouraged to contribute to the family as a whole.  In a family, a child is not a test score.  CPS should be proud that so many families view their schools as such vital supports in their lives and communities; it should be seeking ways to build on these supportive structures rather than tearing them down.  In its frenetic campaign to transform schools, CPS is missing the fundamental fact that children need relationships and stability to learn.

CPS brass may not want to see its schools as families – but it would have a lot more to work with if it would learn from the families who speak, love, and fight for one another. 


2 thoughts on ““How long will you be around?” Turnover, school closings, and community stability

  1. There is no question that the school-home connection is key for student success. If a community are dedicated to a school, the least CPS could do would be to make sure that the leadership in the school are continuing to build strong ties to the community. Schools can’t do it alone and families can’t do it alone. But working together, schools and families can give kids a real boost.

    I blog about issues of learning and leadership at danielbergman323.wordpress.com. I think we would find that we have many shared thoughts.


    • Yes, I want to see more stories of this interdependence. When considered separately, schools and communities are isolated and exposed to external — and dangerous — criticism. When understood to be interlinked, schools and communities have transformative power, as we saw in the Civil Rights movement. It takes time — many years — for these connections to grow, so if schools and teachers want to come into communities and build relationships of trust and respect, they need to be in it for the long haul. CPS gives no sign that they can or will foster such long-term bonds — just the opposite. I look forward to checking out your blog, Daniel!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s